BAITBUS - It’s Not Gay The First Time, That's What We Tell Him LOL 12 min

12 minBait Bus - 261.6k Views -

BrokeStraightBoys: My First Time Getting Fucked 13 min

13 minBlumedia - 584.4k Views -

Straight Ben Gets Fucked For the First Time - RealityDudes 6 min

6 minReality Dudes - 1.4M Views -

First Time Bareback Dick Practice 4 Straight Roommate B4 Orgy! 10 min

10 minNextDoorStudios Official - 1.3M Views -

Straight boy tries out the cruising experience for the first time 12 min

12 minBLESSEXXX GAY - 350.9k Views -

HETEROFLEXIBLE - Curious Straight Barely Can Take His Buddy's Massive Cock During First Time Anal 9 min

9 minHeteroflexible - 216.2k Views -

STRAIGHT STEP-BRO TRIES BIG BARE COCK FOR FIRST TIME! HUGE CLSOEUP CREAMPIE! 40 min

40 minGayduplo Official - 266.8k Views -

Straight guy suffering in the 22 CM roll for the first time 3 min

3 minBrenao22Cm -

BrokeStraightBoys: Straight Boy First Time For Dick 13 min

13 minBlumedia - 328.5k Views -

swallowing straight best friend first time 7 min

7 minMydarkestsecret -

First Time Fuck For Straight Hot Newbie - Trevor Harris, Alessandro Drago - NextDoorBuddies 12 min

12 minNextDoorStudios Official - 401.4k Views -

18 Year Old Straight Amateur Nate Wayne Takes Cock From Behind For A First Time - Latin Leche 17 min

17 minLatin Leche - 3.1M Views -

A Young Straight Jock is Spanked on Video for the First Time 2 min

2 minSpankingstraightboys - 60.4k Views -

Straight guy fucking hot ass first time 2 min

2 minLongslong1451 -

This curious boy thinks I’m looking for a place to rent, but I’m really looking for ass to fuck 13 min

13 minLatin Leche - 511.6k Views -

Young Straight Male Gets His Anal Cherry Popped Bareback Style 11 min

11 minNextDoorStudios Official - 1.2M Views -

ActiveDuty - First Timers Compilation 43 min

43 minActiveDuty Official - 934.3k Views -

PREVIEW: Straight Russian student tries gay sex for the first time - "Evgeny" 5 min

5 minLeoTeenLatinos - 9.2k Views -

Straight Dutch student tries gay sex for the first time (PREVIEW) - "Reinder" 5 min

5 minLeoTeenLatinos - 3.8k Views -

Straight latino dudes fucking for first time on camera 8 min

8 minBroolee -

A Straight Blonde Boy Is Spanked By A Gay Man For The First Time 2 min

2 minSpankingstraightboys - 70.3k Views -

German hetero men try gay sex without condom for the first time 20 min

20 minErotikvonnebenan - 15.4k Views -

Straight guy fuck faggot first time 17 min

17 minCamran Mac - 388.8k Views -

Straight Guy First Time Gay Sex 11 min

11 minYummybumbum97 -

STRAIGHT EXPERIMENTING FOR THE FIRST TIME 6 min

6 minIrmaosdotados - 1.1M Views -

Curious straight guy puts his ass for the first time 11 min

11 minBLESSEXXX GAY - 4M Views -

My straight friend gets a nice cock in the ass for the first time 14 min

14 minSteburning29 - 25.3k Views -